Hutchison Port Trust (HPH Trust) started trading with much fanfare on 2012. Listed in SGX, it is touted as the world's first publicly traded container port business trust. HPH Trust owns interest in container port assets in Hong Kong and Shenzhen - two of the busiest ports in the world. In 2013, its container berth handled a combined throughput of 22.8m twenty-foot equivalent unit (TEU).
HPH Trust is one of the thirty components in Straits Times Index (STI), having replaced F&N in 3 April 2013. As of 13 December 2014, it is also the highest yielding stock within STI at 7.8%. On 27 October 2014, the company ended the third quarter with an operating profit of HK$1.24 billion, a 3.5% increase year-on-year.
Given the high dividend that HPH Trust pays out every year, one should be prudent and check whether these dividends are sustainable into the future. The key objective of the Trustee-Manager was stated in the 2013 Annual Report as the following: "... to provide unitholders with stable and regular distributions and long-term growth in distributions per unit (DPU)" However, a quick look at the DPU since IPO was actually decreasing.
This also points out the deceptive nature of dividends yield. Dividend yield is based on past dividends and definitely not indicative of future dividends. Furthermore, dividend yield is based on current stock price and this means that falling stock price inflates dividend yield. For instance, HPH Trust indicated that it is distributing 45.88 HK cents in its IPO Prospectus and that translated to 5.8% dividend yield based on IPO price of US$1.01. However, due to the subsequent price fall to US$0.78, the yield had been bumped up to 7.5%. Hence, a lesson to take home is that stock purchase should not be based solely on the dividend yield number.
Besides the falling distributions, there are also a few points that does not paint a rosy picture of its financials. The first point is the enormous payout ratio. In 2011, the payout ratio is 167%. Next year, it increased to 199% and subsequently stood at 213% in 2013. Such high numbers indicated the distributions were likely unsustainable and that might have been the reason why distributions were falling.
The trust might be able to give out that much dividends with its positive operating cash flow but quick inspection of the cash pile over the years indicated that it is dipping into its coffers to give such high dividends. In other words, the distributions for the past 3 years are unlikely to be sustainable. The Trust must find ways increase its profits otherwise unitholders will be looking at reduced distributions.
Another point of concern is the liabilities of the Trust. While the debt to assets ratio are pretty reasonable at below 50%, we can see that significant portion of the liabilities have been transferred to Current Liabilities recently. Current Liabilities are debts and obligations due within one year and with significant increase in that amount, a cut in dividend might be plausible in the near future.
With all these data, is HPH Trust properly valued at US$0.69? Analysts opinions were quite differing with UBS having at TP of US$0.67 and DBS at US$0.78. However, one common point in both reports was that the management was considering whether to match cash flow generation to distribution payout more closely. Given that cash flow were negative in 2012 and 2013, distributions look to be suppressed in the mid- to long-term.
Having bought HPH Trust at US$0.68 way back in 21 November 2013, I am fairly pessimistic about the dividend outlook. However, since I am comfortable with dividend yield above 6.5%, I will hold on to it until capital gains (around US$0.725) justify me switching out to other dividend stocks.
